The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) has been the subject of repeated regulatory overhauls, rescissions, litigation, and political controversy. The latest chapter began on July 31, 2026, when the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) jointly issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) proposing what they characterize as targeted amendments to their CRA regulations. Although the proposal would substantially raise the asset thresholds determining which CRA examination procedures apply to banks and eliminate or reduce certain compliance and data-reporting requirements, it also raises important questions about the future of CRA regulation, particularly because the Federal Reserve did not join the proposal.

In this week’s episode of the Consumer Finance Monitor Podcast, the host of our podcast show, Alan Kaplinsky (founder, former leader for 25 years and now Senior Counsel of our Consumer Financial Services Group) was joined by three individuals with extensive CRA experience and different perspectives on the proposal: Dr. Kenneth H. Thomas, a nationally recognized CRA expert and founder and CEO of Community Development Fund Advisors; Greg Thomas, president and chief investment officer of Community Development Fund Advisors, who brings substantial investment management experience to the discussion; and Ballard Spahr partner, Scott Coleman, who has represented banks in a wide variety of regulatory and transactional matters for more than 30 years and has extensive CRA experience.

Our discussion examined the history leading to the current proposal, its most significant provisions, the potential consequences for banks and community development activities, and what banks should be doing now. Several themes emerged that deserve particular attention.

The Federal Reserve’s Absence Raises Questions About the Future of CRA Regulation

One of the most interesting aspects of the NPRM is that it was issued jointly by the OCC and FDIC without the participation of the Federal Reserve. This is particularly noteworthy given that all three agencies participated in the 2023 CRA final rule and the subsequent 2025 proposal to rescind that rule.

As we discussed, the regulatory history has been anything but linear. The OCC adopted a substantially revised CRA rule in 2020, acting independently of the other agencies. That rule was subsequently suspended and rolled back in 2021. The three agencies then worked together on a new regulatory framework, culminating in the 2023 final rule. That rule was challenged by the banking industry, and a federal district court in Texas issued a preliminary injunction in March 2024, concluding, among other things, that the agencies had likely exceeded their statutory authority in certain respects. The agencies subsequently proposed rescinding the 2023 rule in 2025.

Rather than simply restore the pre-2023 regulations, however, the OCC and FDIC have now proposed targeted amendments to that framework.

Scott discussed the possibility that the Federal Reserve’s absence reflects both institutional and substantive differences between the agencies. The Fed has historically taken a different approach to CRA reform, including differences concerning how CRA performance should be measured and which activities should receive consideration.

We also explored whether the absence of the Fed could ultimately produce different CRA requirements depending on which federal banking agency supervises a particular institution. Scott believes that a permanent regulatory split is unlikely, although he acknowledged that it is a possibility. He also observed that if the Fed adopted a more burdensome framework than the OCC and FDIC, state member banks might have an incentive to consider changing their regulatory status.

The possibility of different CRA regimes is an important issue that banks should follow as the rulemaking proceeds.

The Proposed Increase in Asset Thresholds Could Dramatically Change CRA Examinations

Perhaps the most consequential feature of the NPRM for community banks is its proposed increase in the asset thresholds used to determine the applicable CRA examination procedures.

Under the proposal:

  • A small bank would generally be an institution with less than $1 billion in assets, compared with the current threshold of approximately $412 million.
  • An intermediate small bank would generally have between $1 billion and $10 billion in assets, compared with the current upper threshold of approximately $1.6 billion.
  • A bank generally would not be subject to the large-bank examination framework until it exceeded $10 billion in assets.

The agencies estimate that approximately 604 FDIC-supervised banks would move from intermediate small bank to small bank status. Greg estimated that approximately 800 banks supervised by the FDIC and OCC collectively would move into the small-bank category.

These changes could substantially reduce the regulatory obligations of many institutions. Small banks generally are evaluated under a lending test, while intermediate small banks are evaluated under both a lending test and a community development test. The proposed changes would therefore eliminate the separate community development test for many banks that currently are subject to it.

Ken questioned the rationale for the proposed $1 billion threshold, suggesting that it appears to have been selected largely because it is a convenient round number. Scott observed that the $10 billion threshold has a more established regulatory significance, since it is used in other federal banking laws, including the Dodd-Frank Act’s threshold for CFPB supervision.

The NPRM also seeks comment on alternative thresholds, including thresholds aligned with Small Business Administration size standards and a possible $30 billion upper limit for intermediate small banks.

Importantly, Greg cautioned that banks should not assume that moving into a less demanding examination category will necessarily improve their CRA ratings. His firm’s analysis indicates that 23% of intermediate small banks receive outstanding ratings on their community development tests, compared with only 7% receiving outstanding ratings on their lending tests.

Eliminating the community development test could therefore remove an important opportunity for some banks to offset less impressive lending performance through community development activities.

Greg also cautioned banks against assuming that electing the proposed small-bank examination procedures will necessarily improve their chances of obtaining an outstanding rating. Banks that are already performing well under their existing examination procedures may be better off retaining those procedures if the proposal ultimately permits them to do so.

Changes to Community Development Activities and Advance Confirmation of CRA Credit

The NPRM proposes significant changes to the treatment of community development activities. One particularly constructive feature, in Greg’s view, is the proposed formal process through which banks could obtain advance confirmation from their regulators that a particular investment or activity qualifies for CRA credit.

Currently, banks may make substantial investments without knowing with certainty whether those investments will receive CRA consideration until their next examination, potentially years later. That uncertainty can create considerable internal friction among treasury, compliance, and legal departments and can delay or prevent investments from being approved.

Greg believes advance confirmation could materially reduce that uncertainty and encourage additional community development investments. Banks would have greater confidence that their investments will receive the anticipated regulatory treatment before committing capital.

Greg also discussed the evolution of CRA investing. Historically, CRA investments were often viewed by bank treasurers and CFOs as a regulatory expense rather than an investment with meaningful financial characteristics. That attitude is changing.

  1. Greater emphasis on investment returns and liquidity. Banks increasingly want CRA investments that provide attractive financial characteristics rather than simply tying up capital.
  2. Better documentation and measurement of community impact. Banks want to know precisely where their investments are going, which assessment areas and communities are benefiting, and how many families are being helped.
  3. Greater emphasis on qualitative characteristics. The responsiveness and complexity of an investment can be important in determining the amount of CRA consideration it receives.

Greg explained that Community Development Fund Advisors has developed an investment approach designed to combine meaningful community impact with attractive financial characteristics, including liquidity and capital efficiency. He also discussed his firm’s analysis of publicly available CRA performance evaluations, which suggests that banks making more complex community development investments may achieve comparable CRA ratings with substantially lower dollar amounts of investment.

The discussion highlights an important point: CRA investing need not be viewed simply as a regulatory cost. Properly structured investments can provide meaningful community benefits while also meeting banks’ financial objectives.

Does the Proposal Undermine the Traditional Role of Community Development?

Not everyone views the proposed changes favorably.

Ken expressed particular concern about eliminating the separate community development test for intermediate small banks. He emphasized that CRA was designed to impose greater responsibilities on larger banks because they receive greater benefits from the federal banking system. In his view, as banks grow, their responsibilities should extend beyond ordinary lending to include meaningful community development lending, investments, and services.

He also believes that the community development test provides banks with an important opportunity to demonstrate their commitment to their communities and should not be eliminated merely because a bank has crossed a newly established asset threshold.

Ken was also critical of another aspect of the proposal: its restrictions on CRA-eligible donations to community organizations, including a proposed 15% uprate and expense limitation. He views these restrictions as an unnecessary attack on community organizations and suggested that they may reflect the highly publicized dispute between the National Community Reinvestment Coalition and KeyBank concerning the renewal of a community benefit agreement.

Ken cautioned banks about entering into community benefit agreements with outside organizations, which he believes can create difficult long-term obligations. He expressed a preference for bank-controlled community benefit plans developed and approved through the bank’s own governance process.

These issues illustrate that the proposal is not simply about reducing compliance burdens. It also reflects competing views about the proper role of banks, community organizations, and regulators in promoting community development.

The Proposal’s Biggest Shortcoming: Failure to Modernize CRA Assessment Areas

Despite the many changes in the NPRM, Ken identified what he considers its most significant shortcoming: the failure to modernize CRA assessment areas to account for the realities of digital banking.

Under the existing framework, CRA assessment areas remain largely tied to a bank’s physical branches and other facilities. That approach made considerably more sense when banking was predominantly conducted through physical locations. It is much less appropriate in an industry in which banks increasingly obtain deposits and make loans through online and mobile channels.

Ken emphasized that branchless banks, including credit card banks, fintech banks, and internet banks, can obtain deposits from customers throughout the country while having CRA obligations focused primarily on the geographic area surrounding a relatively limited physical presence, often in states such as Delaware, South Dakota, and Utah.

He estimates that branchless banks collect at least $2 trillion, or approximately 10% of the nation’s deposits, much of it originating in major metropolitan areas. Yet, under the existing place-based assessment framework, those banks may have no meaningful obligation to reinvest in the communities from which they obtain those deposits.

Ken advocated a deposit-based approach under which a bank obtaining more than 5% of its deposits from a particular area would be required to reinvest a proportionate amount in that area. He noted that a variation of this concept appeared in the OCC’s 2020 CRA rule but was subsequently abandoned.

Scott agreed with Ken that the failure to address deposit-based assessment areas is a significant flaw in the current proposal. In his view, the industry has changed substantially, and CRA cannot remain effective if its assessment methodology does not reflect where banks actually obtain their deposits.

This is an especially important issue for institutions with substantial online banking operations and relatively few branches. The agencies have an opportunity to modernize CRA in a way that reflects the current banking environment. Their failure to do so is disappointing.

Strategic Plans: Some Improvements, but Limited Appeal

The NPRM also attempts to make the strategic plan option more workable by providing for pre-filing consultation and clarifying the process for obtaining regulatory approval.

Scott believes these changes will be helpful for certain institutions, particularly banks with specialized business models, unusual geographic footprints, or nontraditional community development strategies. However, he does not expect the changes to make strategic plans substantially more attractive to most banks.

Banks that can satisfy their CRA obligations under the ordinary examination procedures generally have little incentive to assume the additional burden of developing and obtaining approval for a strategic plan.

Ken noted that only 79 banks currently operate under approved strategic plans across the OCC, FDIC, and Federal Reserve. Although he expects the proposed changes to encourage some additional banks to consider this option, he remains skeptical of strategic plans generally, expressing concern that they can amount to a form of self-regulation.

State CRA Laws Could Become More Important

We also discussed the continuing significance of state CRA laws.

Scott noted that several states have adopted their own CRA requirements. Depending on the applicable state law, those requirements may apply to institutions not covered by federal CRA, including mortgage companies and other nonbank financial institutions, or may impose additional obligations on institutions subject to federal CRA.

The proposed federal changes do not eliminate those state requirements. Indeed, if state regulators and community organizations view the NPRM as a substantial retreat from existing CRA obligations, states may become more active in this area.

This is another reason banks and nonbank financial institutions should not assume that a reduction in federal CRA requirements will necessarily translate into a corresponding reduction in their overall regulatory obligations.

What Should Banks Do Now?

Perhaps the most practical part of our discussion concerned what banks should do while the proposal remains pending.

Ken’s advice was straightforward: banks should understand the NPRM and be prepared to explain its potential implications to their senior management and boards, but they should not spend substantial sums on consultants or undertake major changes to their CRA programs prematurely.

He offered different suggestions depending on the bank’s asset size:

  • A $500 million bank should continue its existing community development activities because those activities may still provide valuable consideration toward an outstanding rating under the small-bank framework.
  • A $2 billion bank should continue its investment and service activities, which may remain important under the intermediate small bank framework or provide a basis for electing more comprehensive examination procedures.
  • An $8 billion bank should carefully consider whether it would be advantageous to remain subject to the larger-bank examination procedures, particularly if it already has the necessary data collection and compliance infrastructure in place.

Greg similarly advised banks that are already making significant CRA investments not to change their investment strategies simply because of the proposed rule. CRA investments often require substantial advance planning, and there is considerable uncertainty about whether and when the proposal will become effective.

Both Ken and Greg emphasized that the agencies’ previous CRA reform efforts have encountered significant obstacles. Even if the current proposal is finalized, its implementation may not occur until 2028 or 2029.

What Will CRA Look Like Three Years From Now?

We concluded the podcast by asking each guest to predict what CRA compliance will look like three years from now.

Greg’s prediction was that there will be more uncertainty. He expects the broader trends in CRA compliance and community development activity to continue, even as banks and regulators contend with another round of regulatory changes.

Ken was even more skeptical about the prospects for the current proposal. He pointed out that even if the rule becomes effective, CRA examinations conducted in 2029 could involve complicated transition issues because of the existing three-year examination lookback period. He also observed that by 2029 there will be a new presidential administration, which could once again seek to reverse the regulatory direction.

Ken’s preferred outcome, particularly as CRA approaches its 50th anniversary in 2027, would be to retain the 1995 regulatory framework while updating it to reflect modern banking practices. He specifically advocated incorporating a deposit-based assessment area requirement, along with some of the more useful features of prior reform efforts.

Scott agreed with Ken and Greg that the 1995 regulations are likely to remain the governing framework.

The discussion reinforced a central lesson for banks: CRA reform has become an unusually uncertain and politically contentious regulatory undertaking. Although the OCC and FDIC’s proposal contains potentially significant changes, banks should be careful not to assume that those changes will necessarily become effective in their current form or that they will remain in place for the long term.

To hear our complete discussion, including our guests’ detailed analysis of the proposed examination thresholds, community development investments, assessment areas, strategic plans, and practical recommendations for banks, listen to this week’s Consumer Finance Monitor Podcast.